{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in the United States consistently sold for higher prices than it did the year prior. However, that trend has finally come to a halt. Recent nationwide data from October indicates that the median sale price of homes has dipped slightly below last year's level, marking the first annual drop since spring 2023. Concurrently, the housing supply has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have plummeted to their lowest levels in over ten years (excluding the initial pandemic months), and roughly 20% of listings have experienced price reductions.

The flip side to this is that financing has become more costly. The typical rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has risen back into the mid-7% range recently, following a brief period of decline. Thus, while buyers find themselves in a stronger negotiating position, many households still face challenges managing their monthly payments.

This unique situation offers an interesting dynamic. With sellers witnessing fewer offers and longer times on the market, the initial list price and terms presented are becoming more negotiable. If you're in the market for a home this winter, there are various aspects that might be negotiated, which you should discuss with your agent and lender.

Understanding the Impact of Price Fluctuations

A national price decrease of less than half a percent doesn't indicate a large-scale crash, nor does it imply that home prices are falling uniformly across the board. Some high-value coastal areas with limited inventory still report significant price increases, while several large metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced price declines of several percentage points compared to last year. It's essential to focus on the specifics of your local market rather than the national trends.

The national figures signal a shift in power dynamics. When homes linger on the market longer and numerous listings chase after fewer buyers, sellers tend to be more amenable to negotiations. This flexibility can manifest in price reductions, but often it appears in the sale terms as well.

Price Is Just One Element

Many homebuyers concentrate solely on the purchase price, but in an environment of high interest rates, factors such as monthly payments and the upfront cash required at closing can be even more critical. Reducing the purchase price by a few thousand dollars may slightly lower your loan amount, but reallocating that money could have a more significant impact on your financial situation. Common negotiation points in a slower market often include:

  • A lower sale price compared to the listing price
  • A seller contribution towards closing costs
  • Completion of repairs prior to closing or a credit instead of repairs
  • Seller-funded contribution to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or schedule that accommodates your needs
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings with the purchase

Your real estate agent can provide insights into how sellers locally are responding and assist you in determining which aspects to prioritize in your offer. The objective is to request what significantly improves your situation rather than attempting to negotiate for everything.

Using Closing Cost Credits to Alleviate Upfront Cash Needs

Generally, closing costs can amount to a few percent of the loan value on top of the down payment. For many first-time buyers, finding this cash can be the most difficult part of the process. A seller credit can offset some of these costs, decreasing the amount of money needed at closing.

However, there are limits to consider. Many loan programs restrict how much a seller can contribute, often ranging between 3% and 9% of the sale price, depending on the type of loan and down payment size, and a credit usually can't exceed your actual closing expenses. It's wise to check with your lender ahead of time to know what your particular loan permits to ensure any requests in your offer adhere to the guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates hovering above 7%, one of the most beneficial offers a seller could make may involve reducing your interest rate. There are two primary options.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to lower your interest rate throughout the loan's term. Each point equates to 1% of the loan amount, and the rate reduction can vary based on the lender and market conditions. If you anticipate holding onto the loan for many years, a permanent buydown could be financially advantageous.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, would lower your payment for the first year or two. In a typical scenario, the rate is reduced by two percentage points for the first year and one point for the second, subsequently reverting to the original rate. For a $350,000 loan at around 7.34%, monthly payments would roughly start at about $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the payment would drop to about $1,952 for the first year and rise to around $2,176 for the second year before returning to the original amount in the third year. This arrangement may cost just over $8,000 in total, which a seller might prefer to fund rather than lowering the sale price equivalently.

While a temporary buydown can provide immediate relief, it's not a permanent solution. You must ensure that you can manage the full payment once the discount phases out, and lenders typically qualify you based on that full amount. If rates decrease later, refinancing could be a possibility, but it's uncertain when or if that will occur.

Keep the Home Inspection in Mind

During the frenzy of the market, many buyers opted to forgo inspections or limited their requests to enhance their chances in bidding wars. However, in a softer market, you have less pressure to sacrifice these protections. A comprehensive home inspection provides valuable insights into the state of the roof, HVAC system, plumbing, electrical work, and foundation before you finalize your commitment.

If the inspection raises any issues, your agent can guide you on whether to seek repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Credits can often be easier to manage than seller-conducted repairs as you oversee how the repairs are handled, but the best choice depends on the specific problems and your loan's stipulations.

Prioritize Securing Your Financing

Your bargaining power diminishes considerably if your financing is unstable. When presented with multiple offers, sellers typically favor buyers who appear most likely to successfully close. Before diving deeply into your home search, obtain comprehensive preapproval instead of a quick prequalification, have a clear understanding of your maximum comfortable monthly payment beyond just your highest allowable loan amount, and evaluate loan estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender about how they would address seller contributions or buy-downs to prevent any surprises as you proceed.

Essential Questions for Your Agent

  • What is the average time homes spend on the market here, and how frequently are prices reduced?
  • Will a reduction in price, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown most effectively support my budget?
  • How do the specifics of this home's condition and history impact what I might propose?
  • Which contingencies should I retain in my offer to safeguard myself?

Final Thoughts

A downturn in the market does not equate to a bargain, especially when mortgage rates are on the rise again. Yet, it provides well-prepared buyers the chance to tailor terms of a deal that align with their financial situation. By obtaining solid financing, having a clear vision of your needs, and leveraging advice from your agent and lender, you may capitalize on more favorable terms than what was conceivable a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI